Posts Tagged ‘#PSCsocial’

The Results

By:  Cole Francis, Senior Solution Architect, The PSC Group, LLC

Let’s just say that I had a situation where I was calling a third-party API to return valuable information, but that third-party service occasionally failed.  What I discovered through recursion is that 1 out of every 3-5 calls succeeded, but it wasn’t guaranteed.  Therefore, I couldn’t simply wrap my core logic in a hard-coded iterative loop and expect it to succeed.  So, I was relegated to either coming up with a way to write some custom Retry logic to handle errors and reattempt the call or locating and existing third-party package that offers this sort of functionality as not to reinvent the proverbial wheel.

Fortunately, I stumbled across a .NET NuGet Package called Polly.   After reading the abstract about the offering (Click Here to Read More About the Polly Project), I discovered that Polly is a .NET compatible library that complies with transient-fault-handling logic by implementing policies that offer thread-safe resiliency to Retry, Circuit Breaker, Timeout, Bulkhead Isolation, and Fallback logic, and in a way that is very easy to implement inside a .NET project codebase.  I also need to point out that Polly targets .NET 4.0, .NET 4.5 and .NET Standard 1.1.

While Polly offers a plethora of capabilities, many of which I’ll keep in my back pocket for a rainy day, I was interested in just one, the Retry logic.  Here’s how I implemented it.  First, I included the Polly NuGet Package in my solution, like so:

The Results

Next, I included the following lines of code when calling the suspect third-party Web API:

// Here is my wait and retry policy, with 250 millisecond wait intervals.
// It will attempt to call the API 10 times.
  .Handle(e => (e is Exception))
  .WaitAndRetry(10, attempt => TimeSpan.FromMilliseconds(250))
  .Execute(() =>
    // Your core logic should go here!  
    // If an exception is thrown by the called object, 
    // then Polly will wait 250ms and try again for a total of 10 times.
    var response = CallToSuspectThirdPartyAPI(input);

That’s all there really is to it, and I’m only scratching the surface when it comes to Polly’s full gamut of functionality.  Here’s a full list of Polly’s capabilities if you’re interested:

  1. Retry – I just described this one to you.
  2. Circuit Breaker – Fail fast under struggling conditions (you define the conditions and thresholds).
  3. Timeout – Wait until you hit a certain point, and then move on.
  4. Bulkhead Isolation – Provides fault isolation, so that certain failing threads don’t fault the entire process.
  5. Cache – Provides caching (temporary storage and retrieval) capabilities.
  6. Fallback – Anticipates a potential failure and allows a developer to provide an alternative course of action if a potential failure is ever realized.
  7. PolicyWrap – Allows for any (and all) of the previously mentioned policies to be combined, so that different programmatic strategies can be exercised when different faults occur.

Thanks for reading, and keep on coding!  🙂

The Results

Author:  Cole Francis, Senior Solution Architect @ The PSC Group, LLC

Download the Source Code for This Example Here!


Traditionally speaking, creating custom Microsoft Windows Services can be a real pain.  The endless and mind-numbing repetitions of using the InstallUtil command-line utility and Ctrl+Alt+P attachments to the debug the code from the Microsoft Visual Studio IDE are more than enough to discourage the average Software Developer.

While many companies are now shying away from writing Windows Services in an attempt to get better optics around job failures, custom Windows Services continue to exist in limited enterprise development situations where certain thresholds of caution are exercised.

But, if you’re ever blessed with the dubious honor of having to write a custom Windows Service, take note of the fact that there are much easier ways of approaching this task than there used to be, and in my opinion one of the easiest ways is to use a NuGet package called TopShelf.

Here are the top three benefits of using TopShelf to create a Windows Service:

  1. The first benefit of using TopShelf is that you get out from underneath the nuances of using the InstallUtil command to install and uninstall your Windows Service.
  2. Secondly, you create your Windows Service using a simple and familiar Console Application template type inside Microsoft Visual Studio.  So, not only is it extraordinarily easy to create, it’s also just as easy to debug and eventually transition into a fully-fledged Windows Service leveraging TopShelf. This involves a small series of steps that I’ll demonstrate for you shortly.
  3. Because you’ve taken the complexity and mystery out of creating, installing, and debugging your Windows Service, you can focus on writing better code.

So, now that I’ve explained some of the benefits of using TopShelf to create a Windows Service, let’s run through a quick step-by-step example of how to get one up and running.  Don’t be alarmed by the number of steps in my example below.  You’ll find that you’ll be able to work through them very quickly.

Step 1

The first step is to create a simple Console Application in Microsoft Visual Studio.  As you can see in the example below, I named mine TopShelfCWS, but you can name yours whatever you want.

The Results

Step 2

The second step is to open the NuGet Package Manager from the Microsoft Visual Studio IDE menu and then click on the Manage NuGet Packages for Solution option in the submenu as shown in the example below.

The Results

Step 3

After the NuGet Package Manager screen appears, click on the Browser option at the top of the dialog box, and then search on the words “TopShelf”.  A number of packages should appear in the list, and you’ll want to select the one shown in the example below.

The Results

Step 4

Next, select the version of the TopShelf product that aligns with your project or you can simply opt to use the default version that was automatically selected for you, which is what I have done in my working example.

Afterwards, click the Install button.  After the package successfully installs itself, you’ll see a green checkbox by the TopShelf icon, just like you see in the example below.

The Results

Step 5

Next, add a new Class to the TopShelfCWS project, and name it something that’s relevant to your solution.  As you can see in the example below, I named my class NameMeAnything.

The Results

Step 6

In your new class (e.g. NameMeAnything), add a reference to the TopShelf product, and then inherit from ServiceControl.

The Results

Step 7

Afterwards, right click on the words ServiceControl and implement its interface as shown in the example below.

The Results

Step 8

After implementing the interface, you’ll see two new events show up in your class.  They’re called Start() and Stop(), and they’re the only two events that the TopShelf product relies upon to communicate with the Windows Service Start and Stop events.

The Results

Step 9

Next, we’ll head back to the Main event inside the Program class of the Console Application.  Inside the Main event, you’ll set the service properties of your impending Windows Service.  It will include properties like:

  • The ServiceName: Indicates the name used by the system to identify this service.
  • The DisplayName: Indicates the friendly name that identifies the service to the user.
  • The Description: Gets or sets the description for the service.

For more information, see the example below.

The Results

Step 10

Let’s go back to your custom class one more time (e.g. NameMeAnything.cs), and add the code in the following example to your class.  You’ll replace this with your own custom code at some point, but following my example will give you a good idea of how things behave.

The Results

Step 11

Make sure you include some Console writes to account for all the event behaviors that will occur when you run it.

The Results

Step 12

As I mentioned earlier, you can run the Console Application simply as that, a Console Application.  You can do this by simply pressing the F5 key.  If you’ve followed my example up to this point, then you should see the output shown in the following example.

The Results

Step 13

Now that you’ve run your solution as a simple Console Application, let’s take the next step and install it as a Window Service.

To do this, open a command prompt and navigate to the bin\Debug folder of your project.   *IMPORTANT:  Make sure you’re running the command prompt in Administrator mode* as shown in the example below.

The Results

Step 14

One of the more beautiful aspects of the TopShelf product is how it abstracts you away from all the .NET InstallUtil nonsense.  Installing your Console Application as a Windows Service is as easy as typing the name of your executable, followed by the word “Install”.  See the example below.

The Results

Step 15

Once it installs, you’ll see the output shown in the example below.

The Results

Step 16

What’s more, if you navigate to the Windows Services dialog box, you should now see your Console Application show up as a fully-operable Windows Service, as depicted below.

The Results

Step 17

You can now modify the properties of your Windows Service and start it.  Since all I’m doing in my example is executing a simple timer operation and logging out console messages, I just kept all the Windows Service properties defaults and started my service.  See the example below.

The Results

Step 18

If all goes well, you’ll see your Windows Service running in the Windows Services dialog box.

The Results

Step 19

So, now that your console application is running as a Windows Service, you’re absent the the advantage of seeing your console messages being written to the console. So, how do you debug it?

The answer is that you can use the more traditional means of attaching a Visual Studio process to your running Windows Service by clicking Ctrl + Alt + P in the Visual Studio IDE, and then selecting the name of your running Windows Service, as shown in the example below.

The Results

Step 20

Next, set a breakpoint on the _timer_Elapsed event.  If everything is running and hooked up properly, then your breakpoint should be hit every second, and you can press F10 to step it though the event handler that’s responsible for writing the output to the console, as shown in the example below.

The Results

Step 21

Once you’re convinced that your Windows Service is behaving properly, you can stop it and test the TopShelf uninstallation process.

Again, TopShelf completely abstracts you away from the nuances of the InstallUtil utility, by allowing you to uninstall your Windows Service just as easily as you initially installed it.

The Results

Step 22

Finally, if you go back into the Windows Services dialog box and refresh your running Windows Services, then you should quickly see that your Windows Service has been successfully removed.

The Results


In summary, I walked you through the easy steps of creating a custom Windows Service using the TopShelf NuGet package and a simple C# .NET Console application.

In the end, starting out with a TopShelf NuGet package and a simple Console application allows for a much easier and intuitive Windows Service development process, because it abstracts away all the complexities normally associated with traditional Windows Service development and debugging, resulting in more time to focus on writing better code. These are all good things!

Hi, I’m Cole Francis, a Senior Solution Architect for The PSC Group, LLC located in Schaumburg, IL.  We’re a Microsoft Partner that specializes in technology solutions that help our clients achieve their strategic business objectives.  PSC serves clients nationwide from Chicago and Kansas City.

Thanks for reading, and keep on coding!  🙂